So....to put this BS discussion to rest.....

[Boatymcboatface]

Thanks for the rant, you’ve cured me from wanting to try it. I’ve eyeballed it on the store several times, never wanted to spend that much.

While you’re at it, can you make a rant thread about which type of Mayo to buy? And if the olive oil Mayo is any good? TIA!

Hillmans or nothing!

 

[DRYHEAT]

This ought to stir the pot.

 

[Ricks raft]

Hillmans or nothing! View attachment 1292533

Yeah my wife agrees. And she puts that stuff on everything. Except out west it’s call Best Foods.

 

[PlumLoco]

This ought to stir the pot.
View attachment 1292540

Not really. The jury has been in for decades. Miracle Whip sucks.

 

[Angler]

Real Butter or GTFO.

 

[TonyFanelli]

Sounds like a Challenge.

View attachment 1292504

Mmmmmm challenge with sea salt and canolla oil

 

[Sleek-Jet]

Thanks for the rant, you’ve cured me from wanting to try it. I’ve eyeballed it on the store several times, never wanted to spend that much.

While you’re at it, can you make a rant thread about which type of Mayo to buy? And if the olive oil Mayo is any good? TIA!

No, the olive oil mayo tastes like Miracle Whip, and only psychopaths eat that shit.

Go real or go home. Hellmann's/Best Foods, though Kraft mayo will do in a pinch.

 

[Done-it-again]

I am kind of a butter believer. Use real salted butter and don't worry about the BS about dairy products....blah blah blah

There was a thread on here about butter and what to choose.

In there were many people that believed in the Kerrigolds (or whatever its called) Irish butter from Costco. So many of you were positive I bought $15. worth of it. It sucks.....looks and tastes like friggin margerine. All yellow and not tasty. Doesn't melt the same way of American butter. More oily and if thats what you like so be it.

Just buy your salted butter and zip it.....lol

That is all......

Now onward to solve the Israel-Palestine conflict

Don't try the Kerrigold cheese, its horrbile. Tastes like what I would assume a sheep's ass would taste like.....

 

[BingerFang]

Thanks for the rant, you’ve cured me from wanting to try it. I’ve eyeballed it on the store several times, never wanted to spend that much.

While you’re at it, can you make a rant thread about which type of Mayo to buy? And if the olive oil Mayo is any good? TIA!

The butter is really good, OP has bad taste buds!

 

[LargeOrangeFont]

The butter is really good, OP has bad taste buds!

Truth. Too much BL for all those years

 

[Markus]

Kerrigold is great. There are some very expensive French Echiré butters that are [supposed to be] even tastier, but they are not as good for you as the grass fed Irish stuff.

The funny thing is that only Americans and Germans go crazy about Irish butter. No one else cares, except the Irish.

As to Mayonnaise, Hellman's is very good, but there is a Japanese mayo that is the Kerrigold of mayonnaises. If you Google, I am sure you will find.

For some uses, Vaseline is preferable, though.

Boating season ended early this year.

 

[SHOCKtheMONKEY]

As to Mayonnaise, Hellman's is very good, but there is a Japanese mayo that is the Kerrigold of mayonnaises. If you Google, I am sure you will find.

Kewpie is the Japanese stuff.
Duke's is the American version.

 

[DILLIGAF]

The butter is really good, OP has bad taste buds!

Lol. I had to try it but didnt like it at all. Personal preference of course

 

[sirbob]

As the person that first posted a picture of Kerrygold in that other thread - I don’t know what Costco has to do with that brand of butter?

I never said I buy it there (I don’t).

And as someone whose 4 grandparents were born in Ireland, this was a flavor I came to like in my butter. Just like some other things that many people don’t like - cooked cabbage, boiled potato’s, corn beef etc.

Carry on…

 

[Gelcoater]

Lol. I had to try it but didnt like it at all. Personal preference of course

My wife has picked up raw butter a few times and from a couple of mfg, it’s pretty awesome.
Raw Farms is great. However...I read about recalls on their milk and cheddar. How it didn’t include the butter is anyone’s guess?

Some interesting reading on the benefits of unpasteurized as far as omega 3 (that’s the healthy stuff) that is tossed out the window of pasturized products.

That Irish butter you tried tastes like Oroville Redenbacher butter flavored oil

 

[RogerThat99]

This ought to stir the pot.
View attachment 1292540

NO. NO. NO. NO. @shintoooo - Ban this guy forever. Right now.

I believe Dahmer was given Miracle Whip as a child. Probably the Uni-Bomber also.

 

[angiebaby]

Dangit!! I bought some too because of all the hype. I have a difficult time finding my Organic Valley brand at the supermarket and there's not a real health food store here in Havasu. So I bought some Kerrygold based on the recommendations. Haven't tried it yet. Maybe I will be pleasantly surprised.

 

[DILLIGAF]

Dangit!! I bought some too because of all the hype. I have a difficult time finding my Organic Valley brand at the supermarket and there's not a real health food store here in Havasu. So I bought some Kerrygold based on the recommendations. Haven't tried it yet. Maybe I will be pleasantly surprised.

IMO its oily Angie......

 

[TonyFanelli]

best mayo is the hand made type...ask the emoji

 

[DRYHEAT]

NO. NO. NO. NO. @shintoooo - Ban this guy forever. Right now.

I believe Dahmer was given Miracle Whip as a child. Probably the Uni-Bomber also.

I didn’t say I ate it, I was just stirring the winter pot of controversy.

 

[DRYHEAT]

Dangit!! I bought some too because of all the hype. I have a difficult time finding my Organic Valley brand at the supermarket and there's not a real health food store here in Havasu. So I bought some Kerrygold based on the recommendations. Haven't tried it yet. Maybe I will be pleasantly surprised.

Walmart doesn’t have a health food section?

 

[Cobalt232]

Irish Butter??? Have you not had Irish food? What do you expect?

The butter with the elk on the package is the best. Elk milk is great for making everything.

 

[Done-it-again]

Irish Butter??? Have you not had Irish food? What do you expect?

The butter with the elk on the package is the best. Elk milk is great for making everything.

Pretty sure Challenge butter is NOT made with Elk milk.

 

[Rajobigguy]

I was raised on Oleo and Miracle whip. Not saying there is necessarily any correlation but in two different venue I was voted "most likely to go postal".

 

[Rajobigguy]

Pretty sure Challenge butter is NOT made with Elk milk.

Well crap, does that mean that Land of Lakes isn't made from the breast milk of an Indian maiden?

 

[BingerFang]

Dangit!! I bought some too because of all the hype. I have a difficult time finding my Organic Valley brand at the supermarket and there's not a real health food store here in Havasu. So I bought some Kerrygold based on the recommendations. Haven't tried it yet. Maybe I will be pleasantly surprised.

I love it… therefor you will probably hate it

 

[SBMech]

Honestly it DOES have a certain taste to it, I did not like it the first few times I tried it, Challenge all the way....

Cooking with it however, it imparts a richness to flavors that is excellent, and it does not burn at an very low temp like Challenge.

Like everything, your tastes change as you get older, I crave onions and broccoli and shit these days, when as a younger man I would only eat Taters etc.

 

[angiebaby]

I love it… therefor you will probably hate it

Ha! I tried it this morning and thought it was just like any other butter. Made an egg sandwich. Cooked the California egg in Irish butter and then proceeded to put the Irish butter on my English muffin (is there a rule against that? )

So IDK, maybe Tom just isn’t used to the taste of butter from grass-fed cows. I didn’t notice any difference in texture or melting behavior I’d buy it again. It is a little more yellow though for some reason. Not sure why.

 

[SBMech]

Ha! I tried it this morning and thought it was just like any other butter. Made an egg sandwich. Cooked the California egg in Irish butter and then proceeded to put the Irish butter on my English muffin (is there a rule against that? )

So IDK, maybe Tom just isn’t used to the taste of butter from grass-fed cows. I didn’t notice any difference in texture or melting behavior I’d buy it again. It is a little more yellow though for some reason. Not sure why.

"Fattier" is what I would poorly attempt to describe it....

 

[2Driver]

A freaking butter rant?
Ruined the toast this morning?
Oh how the mighty have fallen.

 

[DILLIGAF]

I was raised on Oleo and Miracle whip. Not saying there is necessarily any correlation but in two different venue I was voted "most likely to go postal".

HAHA....SAME HERE

 

[DILLIGAF]

Ha! I tried it this morning and thought it was just like any other butter. Made an egg sandwich. Cooked the California egg in Irish butter and then proceeded to put the Irish butter on my English muffin (is there a rule against that? )

So IDK, maybe Tom just isn’t used to the taste of butter from grass-fed cows. I didn’t notice any difference in texture or melting behavior I’d buy it again. It is a little more yellow though for some reason. Not sure why.

That must be it.....the grass fed aspect of it. To me its like using oil

 

[TonyFanelli]

That must be it.....the grass fed aspect of it. To me its like using oil

Oil bad! They should invent electric butter

 

[DILLIGAF]

View attachment 1292890

Don't encourage the knucklehead Your GIF does resemble him a bit though

 

[Lunatic Fringe]

Don't encourage the knucklehead Your GIF does resemble him a bit though

Hey now!
I dropped Lorraine off at the airport a bit ago so she could head home.
She'll drive out to your place and kick your butt.

 

[2Driver]

Hey now!
I dropped Lorraine off at the airport a bit ago so she could head home.
She'll drive out to your place and kick your butt.

That would be enough to sleep with one eye open.

 

[DILLIGAF]

Hey now!
I dropped Lorraine off at the airport a bit ago so she could head home.
She'll drive out to your place and kick your butt.

Ahhhhh.....I thought this was happening tomorrow?

 

[Done-it-again]

Well crap, does that mean that Land of Lakes isn't made from the breast milk of an Indian maiden?

Nope. Sorry to bust your saggy titty dream.

 

[Lunatic Fringe]

Ahhhhh.....I thought this was happening tomorrow?

I checked the fridge here at the lake house and your delicate palate would be safe.
No Irish disappointment in God's country.

 

[Racey]

I am kind of a butter believer. Use real salted butter and don't worry about the BS about dairy products....blah blah blah

There was a thread on here about butter and what to choose.

In there were many people that believed in the Kerrigolds (or whatever its called) Irish butter from Costco. So many of you were positive I bought $15. worth of it. It sucks.....looks and tastes like friggin margerine. All yellow and not tasty. Doesn't melt the same way of American butter. More oily and if thats what you like so be it.

Just buy your salted butter and zip it.....lol

That is all......

Now onward to solve the Israel-Palestine conflict

It's grassfed butter, just like grassfed meat it has that strong flavor and lacks the richness of grain fed.

But some people like grass fed over grain, i prefer grain. To each their own.

 

[DILLIGAF]

Hey now!
I dropped Lorraine off at the airport a bit ago so she could head home.
She'll drive out to your place and kick your butt.

I checked the fridge here at the lake house and your delicate palate would be safe.
No Irish disappointment in God's country.

View attachment 1292927

Expected to see some Oleo. Lol

 

[Rajobigguy]

I checked the fridge here at the lake house and your delicate palate would be safe.
No Irish disappointment in God's country.

View attachment 1292927

I prefer the classic package,

 

[DRYHEAT]

Oil bad! They should invent electric butter

They did. It’s called margarine, and the bugs won’t even eat it.