WELCOME TO RIVER DAVES PLACE

Holy shit! A Texas sized train crash and derailment

monkeyswrench

To The Rescue!
Joined
Sep 7, 2018
Messages
29,402
Reaction score
83,879
I'm guessing the driver will be found at fault. Should have never been there, either stop clear, or clear the crossing, never stop on the crossing. Sad deal for the families of the two UP employees. Also kind of a miracle that only two lives were lost.
 

4Waters

Well-Known Member
Joined
Aug 28, 2016
Messages
34,462
Reaction score
87,502
I'm guessing the driver will be found at fault. Should have never been there, either stop clear, or clear the crossing, never stop on the crossing. Sad deal for the families of the two UP employees. Also kind of a miracle that only two lives were lost.
Apparently the truck was stuck there for an hour and nobody thought to call the 800 number
 

Singleton

Well-Known Member
Joined
Feb 5, 2008
Messages
19,174
Reaction score
26,035
I'm guessing the driver will be found at fault. Should have never been there, either stop clear, or clear the crossing, never stop on the crossing. Sad deal for the families of the two UP employees. Also kind of a miracle that only two lives were lost.
Truck got hung up.
Someone dropped the ball on calling the railroad.
 

welldigger00

Well-Known Member
Joined
Aug 18, 2010
Messages
3,767
Reaction score
9,017
Every time I’ve gotten any oversize permit in Texas especially , part of the requirements are measurements of ground clearance, and distance of the last axle on the truck to the first axle on the trailer. The permit company that I use will plan routing accordingly. That looked like a larger than normal oversized load, or what’s called a super load. im surprised they routed it that way. It dont make sense that the pilot dint catch it. Or, the driver was off route. Or, they didn’t pull permits. Or they were routed that way and texdot didn’t realize it was low. No excuse for something that big. It’s not like it was a 320 on a five axle deal. It’s one thing to be tall, and have a pole car up front, and maybe hit a bridge. They don’t really have a low clearance lead pilot. However, anything super load sized usually has to have a route survey ahead of time, that is approved by what ever state you’re in. Either way, it sux. one time I thought I was gonna bottom out, and I creeped up on it slow and set my mirrors low down, and watched and had the windows open, listening and feeling for something. That way I know I can back off of it. Even if I’ve got to push a car out of my way. It’s only happened once, and it was nightmare fuel. It was one of those deals where I was on the approved route, and I pre ran the route on one of my nav apps. It showed train tracks, but you don’t know how high they are off the road bed.
 

Tank

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jul 12, 2008
Messages
21,058
Reaction score
50,415
That shit was CRAAAAAZY!!! holy shit. Train was getting after it!!
That hauling company is fuuuuuuuucked.

Question for the train guys…I take it the two deceased were riding in the engine?
 

welldigger00

Well-Known Member
Joined
Aug 18, 2010
Messages
3,767
Reaction score
9,017
It’s not necessarily the drivers fault on this. If the pilot company did the route survey, and it was approved by Tex dot, the liability will fall on the pilot company. However, every one gets sued into oblivion on this. After watching it a few times, that load is really long, and the driver may not have known he was fucked until it was too late. Also, something like this could be multi trailers, and the jeep made it through, but the low bed, or perimeter trailer may have run aground, and that is that.
 

4Waters

Well-Known Member
Joined
Aug 28, 2016
Messages
34,462
Reaction score
87,502
Every time I’ve gotten any oversize permit in Texas especially , part of the requirements are measurements of ground clearance, and distance of the last axle on the truck to the first axle on the trailer. The permit company that I use will plan routing accordingly. That looked like a larger than normal oversized load, or what’s called a super load. im surprised they routed it that way. It dont make sense that the pilot dint catch it. Or, the driver was off route. Or, they didn’t pull permits. Or they were routed that way and texdot didn’t realize it was low. No excuse for something that big. It’s not like it was a 320 on a five axle deal. It’s one thing to be tall, and have a pole car up front, and maybe hit a bridge. They don’t really have a low clearance lead pilot. However, anything super load sized usually has to have a route survey ahead of time, that is approved by what ever state you’re in. Either way, it sux. one time I thought I was gonna bottom out, and I creeped up on it slow and set my mirrors low down, and watched and had the windows open, listening and feeling for something. That way I know I can back off of it. Even if I’ve got to push a car out of my way. It’s only happened once, and it was nightmare fuel. It was one of those deals where I was on the approved route, and I pre ran the route on one of my nav apps. It showed train tracks, but you don’t know how high they are off the road bed.
It’s not necessarily the drivers fault on this. If the pilot company did the route survey, and it was approved by Tex dot, the liability will fall on the pilot company. However, every one gets sued into oblivion on this. After watching it a few times, that load is really long, and the driver may not have known he was fucked until it was too late. Also, something like this could be multi trailers, and the jeep made it through, but the low bed, or perimeter trailer may have run aground, and that is that.
Great insight and information on how it works in Texas, I'm sure it's fairly similar in all states but thanks for chiming in, learned something. 👍
 

stokerwhore

aka bordsmnj
Joined
Dec 12, 2007
Messages
4,318
Reaction score
4,689
all someone had to do was ground the two rails together with a jumper cable, piece of wire, any metal, etc and it would activate the gate and throw a red stop signal at the nearest control point to the train. dispatcher would see it too. good to do in a pinch while a call is being made
 

DRYHEAT

Well-Known Member
Joined
Sep 6, 2010
Messages
7,530
Reaction score
14,041
It’s not necessarily the drivers fault on this. If the pilot company did the route survey, and it was approved by Tex dot, the liability will fall on the pilot company. However, every one gets sued into oblivion on this. After watching it a few times, that load is really long, and the driver may not have known least he pulled the pin he was fucked until it was too late. Also, something like this could be multi trailers, and the jeep made it through, but the low bed, or perimeter trailer may have run aground, and that is that.
I would really like to think the driver would’ve seen that hump in the crossing, and questioned it, seemed pretty extreme. Maybe watching the mirrors too much. At least he pulled the pin before abandoning truck. Really infuriating if he was really stuck there for an hour. 🙁
 

welldigger00

Well-Known Member
Joined
Aug 18, 2010
Messages
3,767
Reaction score
9,017
I would really like to think the driver would’ve seen that hump in the crossing, and questioned it, seemed pretty extreme. Maybe watching the mirrors too much. At least he pulled the pin before abandoning truck. Really infuriating if he was really stuck there for an hour. 🙁
Id tend to agree, especially if the driver has had alot of seat time in that configuration.
 

coolchange

Lower level functionary
Joined
Jan 1, 2008
Messages
10,589
Reaction score
15,802
all someone had to do was ground the two rails together with a jumper cable, piece of wire, any metal, etc and it would activate the gate and throw a red stop signal at the nearest control point to the train. dispatcher would see it too. good to do in a pinch while a call is being made
How does that work? Signal in the rails ?
 

Kachina26

Inmate #RDP158
Joined
Sep 28, 2007
Messages
10,636
Reaction score
17,714
Apparently the truck was stuck there for an hour and nobody thought to call the 800 number
Damn, that was hard to watch knowing that 2 people died. One night while away from my desk, the emergency light went off with a call to stop all traffic at one of my crossings due to a car on the tracks. When I got back and was briefed, I was told what was up. It was near a yard, so I had camera access. I started looking around and there was no car on my tracks. I called our police and told them the deal. They said to continue to hold traffic. I kept looking around and noticed UP had a train stopped on their tracks on the crossing in question. I looked a little more to the west and discovered that they had hit the car. Our police called and gave me the all clear as the local PD was unable to locate the car. I told her that I located it and it was welded to the front of the train blocking the crossing. I knew the DS on the UP. When she got the call, she quit listening when they told her the street name as it was a street where they commonly did crew changes in Stockton. Unfortunately, the street they needed protected was in Fresno. Nobody hurt, just an old junker taken out of service.

All that to say, maybe somebody did call the number and there was an issue getting the crossing protected. Down near LA, we had CHP get with our MOW guys and secure track protection BEFORE hauling a big load across. I guess they don't do that everywhere as this isn't the only mishap I've seen. I had a lowboy rip out some of my rail outside of Bakersfield.
 

rrrr

Well-Known Member
Joined
Dec 19, 2007
Messages
15,944
Reaction score
35,648
Local news story on the crash. Terrible that two UP employees lost their lives just days before Christmas.

That distillation unit (I think that's what it is) probably took months to build. It was a massive piece of steel. While @welldigger00 provided good info about oversize loads, the last line of defense against an accident is the pilot car driver and the trucker. The crossing had a very obvious and significant rise. A few minutes and some phone calls might have averted tragedy.

 
Last edited:

lbhsbz

Putting on the brakes
Joined
Jan 11, 2010
Messages
13,170
Reaction score
34,036
I would really like to think the driver would’ve seen that hump in the crossing, and questioned it, seemed pretty extreme. Maybe watching the mirrors too much. At least he pulled the pin before abandoning truck. Really infuriating if he was really stuck there for an hour. 🙁
They had an hour to get every vehicle in sight together stem to stern to push that thing off the tracks. Surely the repair bill would be less expensive than the damage incurred this way.

This is the world of "stand around and watch and take video" that we live in now....most are worthless and afraid to make a decision and execute.
 

Waterjunky

RDP Inmate #94
Joined
Sep 24, 2007
Messages
4,929
Reaction score
4,279
They had an hour to get every vehicle in sight together stem to stern to push that thing off the tracks. Surely the repair bill would be less expensive than the damage incurred this way.

This is the world of "stand around and watch and take video" that we live in now....most are worthless and afraid to make a decision and execute.
This looks like farm country. I guarantee something big enough to remove the problem (one way or another 😈) in a real hurry was only minutes away. Then again, the tracks might have sustained damage in the process and caused the same issue.
 

monkeyswrench

To The Rescue!
Joined
Sep 7, 2018
Messages
29,402
Reaction score
83,879
We have a cool switch I can add to Peterbilt’s to avoid this kinda situation where it does an air bag over inflate to get you over the tracks.
Getting semis into event centers for shows sometimes took creativity, like a lowrider in a driveway. Those were only 53ft double drops, like Kentucky or Bekins. Something like this would be really rough. Due to length, just the truck lift may not change the angle enough. Lifting the rear in addition would also help, but then trailer mods may be needed as well, as a lot of the heavy stuff runs a type of walking beam.

I haven't seen how much it weighed, or the overall length. Looked pretty massive, and pretty stout too just looking at the remaining piece by the wrecked building.
 

yz450mm

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jun 10, 2013
Messages
3,606
Reaction score
7,302
Getting semis into event centers for shows sometimes took creativity, like a lowrider in a driveway. Those were only 53ft double drops, like Kentucky or Bekins. Something like this would be really rough. Due to length, just the truck lift may not change the angle enough. Lifting the rear in addition would also help, but then trailer mods may be needed as well, as a lot of the heavy stuff runs a type of walking beam.

I haven't seen how much it weighed, or the overall length. Looked pretty massive, and pretty stout too just looking at the remaining piece by the wrecked building.
The lead locomotive actually lifted up when it hit it, so whatever was on that trailer had to be well into the hundreds of thousands of pounds.
 

Cdog

Well-Known Member
Joined
Apr 8, 2008
Messages
8,543
Reaction score
18,223
Getting semis into event centers for shows sometimes took creativity, like a lowrider in a driveway. Those were only 53ft double drops, like Kentucky or Bekins. Something like this would be really rough. Due to length, just the truck lift may not change the angle enough. Lifting the rear in addition would also help, but then trailer mods may be needed as well, as a lot of the heavy stuff runs a type of walking beam.

I haven't seen how much it weighed, or the overall length. Looked pretty massive, and pretty stout too just looking at the remaining piece by the wrecked building.
When I spec a real Heavy Haul truck usually adding new way suspension, which allows for superior articulation.

Too many variables for either one of us to Monday quarterback from the Internet. I was just offering some information on how options are available on trucks and a lot of people don’t even know exist.
 

Roosky01

Well-Known Member
Joined
Apr 30, 2020
Messages
2,536
Reaction score
8,571
all someone had to do was ground the two rails together with a jumper cable, piece of wire, any metal, etc and it would activate the gate and throw a red stop signal at the nearest control point to the train. dispatcher would see it too. good to do in a pinch while a call is being made
Does this actually work? If so, why didn't we know this at about 8 years old so we could've really stirred up some trouble? 😉
 

rivrrts429

Arch Stanton...
Joined
Jan 4, 2008
Messages
21,509
Reaction score
46,503
They had an hour to get every vehicle in sight together stem to stern to push that thing off the tracks. Surely the repair bill would be less expensive than the damage incurred this way.

This is the world of "stand around and watch and take video" that we live in now....most are worthless and afraid to make a decision and execute.


You’re not moving that load with anything you can see in that video. That load is massive if it lifted the lead locomotive like it did and how many people carry tow straps that could move that thing lol
 

lbhsbz

Putting on the brakes
Joined
Jan 11, 2010
Messages
13,170
Reaction score
34,036
You’re not moving that load with anything you can see in that video. That load is massive if it lifted the lead locomotive like it did and how many people carry tow straps that could move that thing lol
I disagree. You put 10 pickup trucks bumper to bumper, that's more torque and traction that than tractor has.....it's worth a shot, and better than taking a goddam video of the carnage.
 

lbhsbz

Putting on the brakes
Joined
Jan 11, 2010
Messages
13,170
Reaction score
34,036
You’re not moving that load with anything you can see in that video. That load is massive if it lifted the lead locomotive like it did and how many people carry tow straps that could move that thing lol
You need maybe 20% more power and traction than it took to get it stuck there.
 

rivrrts429

Arch Stanton...
Joined
Jan 4, 2008
Messages
21,509
Reaction score
46,503
I disagree. You put 10 pickup trucks bumper to bumper, that's more torque and traction that than tractor has.....it's worth a shot, and better than taking a goddam video of the carnage.


There’s a reason when you see heavy haul push/pull type loads and they’ve got 50k pounds of counter weight on the push/pullers. It’s like dragging a car out of the Glamis dunes uphill.

I still don’t think they have anyone nearby that had the rigging or know how to rig up what you’re describing.
 

OCMerrill

All in...
Joined
Sep 24, 2007
Messages
27,289
Reaction score
11,168
You’re not moving that load with anything you can see in that video. That load is massive if it lifted the lead locomotive like it did and how many people carry tow straps that could move that thing lol
When you see a quad axle tractor stuck....

I cant believe the train could not be stopped after an hr, Seriously?

RIP to those who lost it all.
 

Racey

Maxwell Smart-Ass
Joined
Sep 18, 2007
Messages
22,322
Reaction score
50,681
How does that work? Signal in the rails ?

The way the gates and flashing lights are triggered is by sensing a conductive path between the two rails. This is normally done by the axles on the train being within proximity of the gate (too far away means too high of resistance and it won't trigger). So if you manually trip it with a steel pipe, jumper cables, etc. It will signal that there is a train on the rails there. Throw the gates and lights, and also signal to rail control that there is another train on that section of rail which initiates all the safety procedures.

Here is a great explanation:
 

lbhsbz

Putting on the brakes
Joined
Jan 11, 2010
Messages
13,170
Reaction score
34,036
When you see a quad axle tractor stuck....

I cant believe the train could not be stopped after an hr, Seriously?

RIP to those who lost it all.
I saw at least 3 pickups and a semi/car hauler in the video....if the car hauler, unloaded...got a running start for a few hundred feet (assuming it probably comes in at 30Klbs at least) and hit the front of the heavy haul tractor doing 10mph or so while the heavy haul guy was in reverse with 2 or 3 axles worth of tires spinning....it would have moved. It can't have not moved. Granted, there would be damage and likely injuries, but not deaths and not half a train derailed worth of damages.

Hell, with an hour to work this whole thing out....one could have hand carried a bunch of ballast or dirt or whatever and piled it under the tractor to solve this problem....but that would have required "approval" and someone with initiative to actually solve a problem.

RIP to the poor guys on the train with nowhere to go and best wishes to their families. They are the only victims here. Every outfit involved outside of the railroad should be sued to kingdom come until they're homeless.
 

coolchange

Lower level functionary
Joined
Jan 1, 2008
Messages
10,589
Reaction score
15,802
The way the gates and flashing lights are triggered is by sensing a conductive path between the two rails. This is normally done by the axles on the train being within proximity of the gate (too far away means too high of resistance and it won't trigger). So if you manually trip it with a steel pipe, jumper cables, etc. It will signal that there is a train on the rails there. Throw the gates and lights, and also signal to rail control that there is another train on that section of rail which initiates all the safety procedures.

Here is a great explanation:
Thanks that’s what I was looking for. Guess I could’ve googled it myself. 👍
 

lbhsbz

Putting on the brakes
Joined
Jan 11, 2010
Messages
13,170
Reaction score
34,036
When you see a quad axle tractor stuck....

I cant believe the train could not be stopped after an hr, Seriously?

RIP to those who lost it all.
Keep in mind...everything was moving until it wasn't. All you have to do it get it back to the point just before it wasn't moving...and it will move again under it's own power. In the mechanic world, we use a hammer for that. There's a whole bunch of hammers on wheels sitting there in that video that were worth a shot at the very least.
 

monkeyswrench

To The Rescue!
Joined
Sep 7, 2018
Messages
29,402
Reaction score
83,879
When I spec a real Heavy Haul truck usually adding new way suspension, which allows for superior articulation.

Too many variables for either one of us to Monday quarterback from the Internet. I was just offering some information on how options are available on trucks and a lot of people don’t even know exist.
It's cool that it's an option now, by manufacturers building trucks. 25 years ago, it was a goat rodeo with an old three axle that was never meant to do that stuff. The biggest issue was high centering into the building. Comparatively speaking, our stuff was light, but kingpin to axle riding 8-10" off the ground gets too low really fast.
You’re not moving that load with anything you can see in that video. That load is massive if it lifted the lead locomotive like it did and how many people carry tow straps that could move that thing lol
A single locomotive is something like 200 tons...5 times a normal loaded semi. Multiple locomotives, a bunch of cars, and the speed it was going into the impact...that's a massive amount of energy. You would think it would cut through most anything. The load stuck on the tracks was both very heavy, and very strong.
 

Tankerchief

Member
Joined
Oct 5, 2022
Messages
12
Reaction score
17
Why doesn't anyone call the 800 number and crossing index on the blue sign required to be posted at each rail crossing in the United States?

After so many of these crossing hits, it should be trained to every truck driver, pilot and LEO in the country.
 

OCMerrill

All in...
Joined
Sep 24, 2007
Messages
27,289
Reaction score
11,168
I saw at least 3 pickups and a semi/car hauler in the video....if the car hauler, unloaded...got a running start for a few hundred feet (assuming it probably comes in at 30Klbs at least) and hit the front of the heavy haul tractor doing 10mph or so while the heavy haul guy was in reverse with 2 or 3 axles worth of tires spinning....it would have moved. It can't have not moved. Granted, there would be damage and likely injuries, but not deaths and not half a train derailed worth of damages.

Hell, with an hour to work this whole thing out....one could have hand carried a bunch of ballast or dirt or whatever and piled it under the tractor to solve this problem....but that would have required "approval" and someone with initiative to actually solve a problem.

RIP to the poor guys on the train with nowhere to go and best wishes to their families. They are the only victims here. Every outfit involved outside of the railroad should be sued to kingdom come until they're homeless.
The one miserable saying in life...bad things happen to good people all the time.

Very good points you make for sure .
 
  • Like
Reactions: TPC

OCMerrill

All in...
Joined
Sep 24, 2007
Messages
27,289
Reaction score
11,168
Why doesn't anyone call the 800 number and crossing index on the blue sign required to be posted at each rail crossing in the United States?

After so many of these crossing hits, it should be trained to every truck driver, pilot and LEO in the country.
Heavy haul driver. He should be well trained. There was a massive amount of disconnect for sure. :(
 

bilz

Newly Retired!😁
Joined
Mar 15, 2011
Messages
2,714
Reaction score
4,181
A well placed Tundra woulda got it done! Space Shuttle couldn't hold it back.

RIP to those who passed.
 

Tank

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jul 12, 2008
Messages
21,058
Reaction score
50,415
I’ve always been told two flares on an x pattern in the middle of the track a mile out will stop rail traffic.universal emergency ahead sign
 

DRYHEAT

Well-Known Member
Joined
Sep 6, 2010
Messages
7,530
Reaction score
14,041
I’ve always been told two flares on an x pattern in the middle of the track a mile out will stop rail traffic.universal emergency ahead sign
That train appeared to be hauling ass, I don’t think a mile would’ve been enough for it to stop.🤷‍♂️
 

DRYHEAT

Well-Known Member
Joined
Sep 6, 2010
Messages
7,530
Reaction score
14,041
It's cool that it's an option now, by manufacturers building trucks. 25 years ago, it was a goat rodeo with an old three axle that was never meant to do that stuff. The biggest issue was high centering into the building. Comparatively speaking, our stuff was light, but kingpin to axle riding 8-10" off the ground gets too low really fast.

A single locomotive is something like 200 tons...5 times a normal loaded semi. Multiple locomotives, a bunch of cars, and the speed it was going into the impact...that's a massive amount of energy. You would think it would cut through most anything. The load stuck on the tracks was both very heavy, and very strong.
If that driver wasn’t paying attention and drove that load hard aground, you ain’t gonna push it off the tracks once it’s high centered. The only thing that was gonna move that was two crane’s minimum. Maybe had there been 2 or 3 D10 dozer’s on scene and they could get enough traction. Sad deal all around and it happens way too often.
 

dirtslinger2

Well-Known Member
Joined
Mar 8, 2011
Messages
1,887
Reaction score
4,410
Looked like a tower for a refinery to me, pretty heavy for sure.
It definitely is, looks to be about an 18ft diameter, possibly 100ft tall distillation column. Some refinery is incredibly bummed. These take around a year to build, cost 10's of millions to build, and their replacement T/A timing is planned years in advanced. This royally fucked somebody.
 

riverroyal

Well-Known Member
Joined
Nov 4, 2007
Messages
14,588
Reaction score
20,434
Not one person has mentioned a f150 could pull it off the tracks.

Seriuosly though, horrible preventable lose of lives.
So many errors. Pilot. Driver.
1 hour on tracks? Seems impossible. No cops in that hour? No farmer saying wtf did anyone call the number.
No passer by calling the cops?

I can't believe it was 1 hour.

Many ruined lives by human error.
 

dirtslinger2

Well-Known Member
Joined
Mar 8, 2011
Messages
1,887
Reaction score
4,410
Not one person has mentioned a f150 could pull it off the tracks.

Seriuosly though, horrible preventable lose of lives.
So many errors. Pilot. Driver.
1 hour on tracks? Seems impossible. No cops in that hour? No farmer saying wtf did anyone call the number.
No passer by calling the cops?

I can't believe it was 1 hour.

Many ruined lives by human error.
There's a Sherriff on scene in the video, he's on his motorcycle, not sure what he's doing, cause it doesn't seem like much.
 

DRYHEAT

Well-Known Member
Joined
Sep 6, 2010
Messages
7,530
Reaction score
14,041
Train was going 68 miles an hour when they applied the emergency brakes, the truck was carrying the base of a wind turbine according to this article.

PECOS, Texas — The Union Pacific train involved in Wednesday’s fatal derailment was going about 68 mph before beginning an emergency brake application, the National Transportation Safety Board said in a statement today (Friday, Dec. 20).

Maximum speed on most of UP’s Toyah Subdivision, including in Pecos, is 70 mph.

Two Union Pacific crew members were killed when the train hit a truck stopped on a grade crossing of U.S. Route 285 (Cedar Street) on Wednesday afternoon [see “Two crew members killed …,” TrainsNews Wire, Dec. 19, 2024]. That truck was carrying an oversized load — a base for a wind turbine, which was thrown by the impact into the nearby Pecos Chamber of Commerce building, a former Texas & Pacific Railway station.

All four head-end locomotives and 25 intermodal well units derailed. The event recorder from the lead unit has been recovered and is being transported to the NTSB material lab in Washington.

Still to be determined, the NTSB said, is how long the truck was on the tracks prior to the collision or if anyone had attempted to contact the railroad through the emergency number posted on a placard at the crossing. The agency is also asking eyewitnesses or anyone with video of the collision to contact the NTSB at [email protected].
 
Top