WELCOME TO RIVER DAVES PLACE

For the Real Estate Drop in sales and price Naysayers HOLD ONTO YOUR HATS

Sportin' Wood

Well-Known Member
Joined
Sep 24, 2007
Messages
2,745
Reaction score
8,264
Something else for your consideration.

Here is an example of a lovely home in Kalispell, Montana. I'm sure you could substitute many other areas in the west. In two years, the delta between asking prices Goes from about $550K to $850K. It does not appear a significant investment was made to increase the home's value in two years, save for inflation. (or speculation)

Setting aside mortgage rates (using the current rate), This home will cost an additional $60K in down payment from around slightly over $100K to $160K, and the monthly payment will rise about $1800 a month to nearly $5000 a month. The amount of qualified buyers for this home has dramatically diminished. You can't simply suggest a wealthy equity-rich buyer from out of state will move to this area because that option is tightening with remote work becoming less common and retirement-aged buyers facing a declining population.

Screen Shot 2022-12-31 at 9.36.22 AM.png

Please help me understand how the real estate market will not see a decline in prices. This house, I assume, like many, has a price driven up by speculation. The house is empty and will depreciate quickly as the weather is brutal on unoccupied homes no matter where it is located.

I may be naive, but a change in the interest rate does not price me out of the market as much as dramatic swings in home prices. While I would like to take advantage of rates as we saw in 2021, I believe those created more long-term harm to the economy than good.

If this home returned to 2020 pricing, would this be considered a crash? I think this simple question is the crux of disagreement in this thread. This would be a reduction in asking price from about $850K down to $550K (-$300K)

For some, I think this would feel like a crash; for others, it would feel like a return to normal.

FWIW: I feel this home would sell in hours if the house were priced at $699K, netting the buyer a healthy return on investment, but we don't know how much the mortgage is on this home. I suspect the buyer quickly took equity out of the house and bought additional properties. My gut tells me this is why we have not seen more significant price reductions and maybe the ticking time bomb.

How long before cash flow becomes a problem for the people that own empty homes? STR property that is sitting empty?

What is the actual value of this house? Whatever someone will pay, I guess?
 

Sportin' Wood

Well-Known Member
Joined
Sep 24, 2007
Messages
2,745
Reaction score
8,264
If it is Havasu, several of us have our homes listed here on RDP for rates that are cheaper than going to a hotel, with no added fees. The comfort of a home, is far superior than a hotel IMO.

At the end of the day, this town is freaking packed and the money that is here in the winter isn't going to be staying at The Quality Inn...........

This time of year isn't college kids coming to party in the channel, so the vacancy rate of The Quality Inn isn't an accurate gauge of the Havasu economy.
The comfort of a home vs. a hotel is subjective. I've stayed at some hotels that outweigh some STRs I have stayed at. Granted, in LHC, a hotel will unlikely beat an STR. Again you make my point that RDP is made up primarily of people with money, and the rest should go be poor somewhere else.

Your Winter Money comment is worth further debate. We have a thread lamenting the current increase in transient desert dwellers on this forum. It does not seem that that is the type of people that generate investment. It does not appear they are wanted here, but they are coming.

I spend six months at Islander among the snowbirds. I am lucky enough to be a remote worker. I learn a lot from my snowbird neighbors. IMHO, LHC will be in trouble when these people age out, which will soon happen. Boomers are almost at the point they can't travel. I do not see a lot of investment in attracting GenXers; even if they were, that demographic is small. That leaves the Millennials. How will LHC attract a demographic that does not like fast boats and offroad vehicles?

Snowbirds in Islander are dropping like flies. I suspect that is representative of the LHC winter money you speak of.
 

LargeOrangeFont

We aren't happy until you aren't happy
Joined
Sep 4, 2015
Messages
49,689
Reaction score
76,183
The comfort of a home vs. a hotel is subjective. I've stayed at some hotels that outweigh some STRs I have stayed at. Granted, in LHC, a hotel will unlikely beat an STR. Again you make my point that RDP is made up primarily of people with money, and the rest should go be poor somewhere else.

Your Winter Money comment is worth further debate. We have a thread lamenting the current increase in transient desert dwellers on this forum. It does not seem that that is the type of people that generate investment. It does not appear they are wanted here, but they are coming.

I spend six months at Islander among the snowbirds. I am lucky enough to be a remote worker. I learn a lot from my snowbird neighbors. IMHO, LHC will be in trouble when these people age out, which will soon happen. Boomers are almost at the point they can't travel. I do not see a lot of investment in attracting GenXers; even if they were, that demographic is small. That leaves the Millennials. How will LHC attract a demographic that does not like fast boats and offroad vehicles?

Snowbirds in Islander are dropping like flies. I suspect that is representative of the LHC winter money you speak of.

You are at the Islander for half the year with a SXS. You are one of the people with money :)

Islander is pricing out snowbirds for people like you… empty nesters with the ability to pay. You can get a house in town for the winter for much cheaper.

There are still legions of empty nesters or soon to be empty nesters that want to exit CA but cannot yet, and there is a nearly endless supply of snowbirds fleeing cold weather. I’d argue the winter economy is more stable with less risk than the summer economy. All the snowbird landlords I know have no issue filling their rentals. My friend lost his potential renter at the beginning of December due to a health issue. He had it filled within a week for more $ a month than before.

Most of the snowbirds I know of don’t boat or off-road. Yes some bring their toys, the majority don’t seem to from my perspective.
 

LargeOrangeFont

We aren't happy until you aren't happy
Joined
Sep 4, 2015
Messages
49,689
Reaction score
76,183
That could come back to haunt LHC. It is the primary reason I am coming here in the Winter. I'm reminded of the fun I had.

That is why all the empty nesters want to spend time or live there. The ones that relocate or own houses there will have the grandkids out there and spawn multiple generations of visitors.

Havasu will continue to be a landing spot for CA money for those able to escape.

My kids know nothing else. They want the boating and off road experiences to be a part of their lives.
 

Havasu blue label

Well-Known Member
Joined
Nov 30, 2018
Messages
5,519
Reaction score
3,280
That is why all the empty nesters want to spend time or live there. The ones that relocate or own houses there will have the grandkids out there and spawn multiple generations of visitors.

Havasu will continue to be a landing spot for CA money for those able to escape.

My kids know nothing else. They want the boating and off road experiences to be a part of their lives. My kids enjoy havasu we have a great time there
 

LargeOrangeFont

We aren't happy until you aren't happy
Joined
Sep 4, 2015
Messages
49,689
Reaction score
76,183
same thing happened to Lake Tahoe x 10000

you gotta be a Jeff Bozo or Mark Cuckeburg to by a house there now

Yep the same thing happened to the central coast of CA where I vacationed as a kid.
 

Gonefishin5555

Well-Known Member
Joined
Aug 8, 2020
Messages
1,180
Reaction score
1,796
It’s always going to be in demand for people escaping CA and people escaping the winter cold weather in the rest of US. Real estate prices will settle back down 250-300k starter home 500-600k for a nice updated pool home.
Something else for your consideration.

Here is an example of a lovely home in Kalispell, Montana. I'm sure you could substitute many other areas in the west. In two years, the delta between asking prices Goes from about $550K to $850K. It does not appear a significant investment was made to increase the home's value in two years, save for inflation. (or speculation)

Setting aside mortgage rates (using the current rate), This home will cost an additional $60K in down payment from around slightly over $100K to $160K, and the monthly payment will rise about $1800 a month to nearly $5000 a month. The amount of qualified buyers for this home has dramatically diminished. You can't simply suggest a wealthy equity-rich buyer from out of state will move to this area because that option is tightening with remote work becoming less common and retirement-aged buyers facing a declining population.

View attachment 1184937

Please help me understand how the real estate market will not see a decline in prices. This house, I assume, like many, has a price driven up by speculation. The house is empty and will depreciate quickly as the weather is brutal on unoccupied homes no matter where it is located.

I may be naive, but a change in the interest rate does not price me out of the market as much as dramatic swings in home prices. While I would like to take advantage of rates as we saw in 2021, I believe those created more long-term harm to the economy than good.

If this home returned to 2020 pricing, would this be considered a crash? I think this simple question is the crux of disagreement in this thread. This would be a reduction in asking price from about $850K down to $550K (-$300K)

For some, I think this would feel like a crash; for others, it would feel like a return to normal.

FWIW: I feel this home would sell in hours if the house were priced at $699K, netting the buyer a healthy return on investment, but we don't know how much the mortgage is on this home. I suspect the buyer quickly took equity out of the house and bought additional properties. My gut tells me this is why we have not seen more significant price reductions and maybe the ticking time bomb.

How long before cash flow becomes a problem for the people that own empty homes? STR property that is sitting empty?

What is the actual value of this house? Whatever someone will pay, I guess?
if I can still sell my CA home for 1.4 I would still pay the 800k for this home. It’s a domino effect at play. When I look at homes now the first thing I look at is the value at the beginning of 2020. That is the price I’d like to pay because that is where I see prices heading
 

Sportin' Wood

Well-Known Member
Joined
Sep 24, 2007
Messages
2,745
Reaction score
8,264
You are at the Islander for half the year with a SXS. You are one of the people with money :)

Islander is pricing out snowbirds for people like you… empty nesters with the ability to pay. You can get a house in town for the winter for much cheaper.
I guess I'm working the LAM angle pretty well. :)

I hate to break the news to you, but Islander is not that expensive, and I will challenge you to provide an example of a residence I can purchase in LHC for cheaper than staying here at Islander.

Including my storage unit, I'm $2500 all in for monthly costs including rent, maintenance, insurance, and RV payment. I put $10K down on the RV.

Got a lead on an LHC residence for $10K down and $18K in annual costs?
 

Sportin' Wood

Well-Known Member
Joined
Sep 24, 2007
Messages
2,745
Reaction score
8,264
That is why all the empty nesters want to spend time or live there. The ones that relocate or own houses there will have the grandkids out there and spawn multiple generations of visitors.

Havasu will continue to be a landing spot for CA money for those able to escape.

My kids know nothing else. They want the boating and off road experiences to be a part of their lives.

The trouble is a generalization. All the empty nesters? :)
 

angiebaby

Mountain Mama
Joined
Sep 24, 2007
Messages
4,920
Reaction score
7,041
Who the heck would want to stay at the Quality Inn when there are AirBNB for the same price???

I really don't understand why you respond this way. Perhaps it is my reading of your post, but it comes off as if anyone who stays at the Quality Inn instead of an Air BnB is an idiot. I realize it is difficult to express tone adequately in an online format, so perhaps I’m reading your post incorrectly.

I did a quick search for under $100/night. This is what I found.

Screen Shot 2022-12-31 at 12.11.15 PM.png


Screen Shot 2022-12-31 at 12.11.24 PM.png


Screen Shot 2022-12-31 at 12.11.31 PM.png



Please note the total price. The only ones close to $250 for 3 nights are rooms in someone else's house. Jeff's parents have a dog. That complicates things as well.

My in-laws stayed there because they are on a budget, they have a dog, free breakfast, it's close to a bar and restaurant and close to us. They've stayed in AirBnBs before, but that was not their choice for this trip.
 
Last edited:

LargeOrangeFont

We aren't happy until you aren't happy
Joined
Sep 4, 2015
Messages
49,689
Reaction score
76,183
I guess I'm working the LAM angle pretty well. :)

I hate to break the news to you, but Islander is not that expensive, and I will challenge you to provide an example of a residence I can purchase in LHC for cheaper than staying here at Islander.

Including my storage unit, I'm $2500 all in for monthly costs including rent, maintenance, insurance, and RV payment. I put $10K down on the RV.

Got a lead on an LHC residence for $10K down and $18K in annual costs?

I understand you live in your RV full time but do most of your neighbors? You are talking a buy vs rent situation and most snowbirds rent. We are also talking appreciating vs depreciating assets (Actual RE vs a RV or trailer)

Your sunk housing costs are sitting there in the space, most snowbirds have their sunk housing costs sitting back in the frozen north somewhere. Given that, $2500/month is relatively expensive to live in a parking spot down by the river for half the year. You can get a house with a hot tub for that.

That was why you saw snowbirds with decent rigs parked behind Wal Mart for years…..because it’s free. Those people are wondering why you are paying to park at the Islander.

It is all relative I suppose.

To answer your question… yes many leads. You could have this paid off in 4 years with your equation, renting it out when you aren’t there. After year 4 it is making money, vs costing $18k a year until the end of time.

There are many listings like this.

 
Last edited:

LargeOrangeFont

We aren't happy until you aren't happy
Joined
Sep 4, 2015
Messages
49,689
Reaction score
76,183
The trouble is a generalization. All the empty nesters? :)

Like the generalizations throughout this thread that everyone owning empty rental properties will be forced to sell them? 😉

Yes.. all the empty nesters that are moving to, wanting to move, or already own property there.

There are still more people that want to buy property in Havasu than houses that are available. And I don’t think I’ve ever seen so much construction.

The best time to buy is always today or 20 years ago.
 
Last edited:

LargeOrangeFont

We aren't happy until you aren't happy
Joined
Sep 4, 2015
Messages
49,689
Reaction score
76,183

Havasu blue label

Well-Known Member
Joined
Nov 30, 2018
Messages
5,519
Reaction score
3,280
I really don't understand why you respond this way. Perhaps it is my reading of your post, but it comes off as if anyone who stays at the Quality Inn instead of an Air BnB is an idiot. I realize it is difficult to express tone adequately in an online format.

I did a quick search.

View attachment 1184952

View attachment 1184953

View attachment 1184954


Please note the total price. The only ones close to $250 for 3 nights are rooms in someone else's house. Jeff's parents have a dog. That complicates things as well.

My in-laws stayed there because they are on a budget, they have a dog, it's close to a bar and restaurant and close to us. They've stayed in AirBnBs before, but that was not their choice for this trip.
Really an idiot shit we stay at the island hotel. We own 3 properties in havasu sons own two they stay as well at the island snow birds till April havasu is a great place to chill and make memories with your kids
 

Sportin' Wood

Well-Known Member
Joined
Sep 24, 2007
Messages
2,745
Reaction score
8,264
I understand you live in your RV full time but do most of your neighbors? You are talking a buy vs rent situation and most snowbirds rent. We are also talking appreciating vs depreciating assets (Actual RE vs a RV or trailer)

Your sunk housing costs are sitting there in the space, most snowbirds have their sunk housing costs sitting back in the frozen north somewhere. Given that, $2500/month is relatively expensive to live in a parking spot down by the river for half the year. You can get a house with a hot tub for that.

That was why you saw snowbirds with decent rigs parked behind Wal Mart for years…..because it’s free. Those people are wondering why you are paying to park at the Islander.

It is all relative I suppose.

To answer your question… yes many leads. You could have this paid off in 4 years with your equation, renting it out when you aren’t there. After year 4 it is making money, vs costing $18k a year until the end of time.

There are many listings like this.

Is that not a trailer in your example? I'm quickly becoming convinced I am an idiot because I just can't visualize a $100K single-wide mobile home in a park north of town gaining value and making me money. This is why I'm too poor for RDP. When I live there, I'll turn to a life of crime.

My Islander neighbors are split bout 50/50 between Full-time Rv and homeowners. The homeowners mostly own multiple revenue-generating properties. The full-timers sold mostly everything to fund the last blast before the glue factory. Mostly my neighbors are financially set at a level I will never achieve.

We can debate all we like on the web, one side is gonna be right and the other is going to try and explain that they claimed something different.

Just to be clear. I am praying, hoping, and doing voodoo dances that the economy crashes so hard people bleed, and housing tanks to unbelievable levels. BUT It's highly unlikely what I want will happen, so I will be satisfied with a return to 2019 prices.
 

LargeOrangeFont

We aren't happy until you aren't happy
Joined
Sep 4, 2015
Messages
49,689
Reaction score
76,183
Is that not a trailer in your example? I'm quickly becoming convinced I am an idiot because I just can't visualize a $100K single-wide mobile home in a park north of town gaining value and making me money. This is why I'm too poor for RDP. When I live there, I'll turn to a life of crime.

My Islander neighbors are split bout 50/50 between Full-time Rv and homeowners. The homeowners mostly own multiple revenue-generating properties. The full-timers sold mostly everything to fund the last blast before the glue factory. Mostly my neighbors are financially set at a level I will never achieve.

We can debate all we like on the web, one side is gonna be right and the other is going to try and explain that they claimed something different.

Just to be clear. I am praying, hoping, and doing voodoo dances that the economy crashes so hard people bleed, and housing tanks to unbelievable levels. BUT It's highly unlikely what I want will happen, so I will be satisfied with a return to 2019 prices.

Yes and that trailer beats the operating cost model you laid out. You could put $10k down and be into that for under 10k/year all in.

To be fair I don’t know if that was deeded land or not, but even so we are talking about appreciating vs depreciating assets.. in 10 years what will that trailer be worth? What will the RV be worth?

Even if it gains no value you can make a return on it, probably enough to make it “free” or nearly free vs $2500/month now.

But no, it isn’t the Islander.

Im 100% fine with the voodoo dances for economic collapse, at least you admit it. The question becomes how long are you going to wait until people are bleeding in the streets? What if we only return to 2020 prices? Will you ever buy?

My point is that in RDP land the economy has supposed to have been brought to its knees every year for the last 7 years. In that 7 years you could have easily doubled your net worth without even trying.

There are members here that thought it was coming in 2018 and unloaded all their crap… only to pay more to get back into crap after.

If it does not happen this next year, how long are you prepared to wait? What’s the opportunity cost of waiting? If is does happen this year, and you buy, what if it gets worse in 2024 and beyond?

You have first mover advantage now, but you probably won’t get bottom dollar
(whatever that will end up being).

If you bought in 2008 when opportunity was in the air, does that 10-15% price delta from 08 to 11 really even matter today?
 

mesquito_creek

Well-Known Member
Joined
Sep 25, 2009
Messages
3,948
Reaction score
6,911
Fun fact: 2021 Forbes list of 400 billionaires, only 24 were in real estate (6%). And I am will to bet none of them did it by timing the market.

Invest at an early age and invest consistently and 30 years later everyone is a winner.

Reminds me of the bet Warren Buffet had for 1 million dollars that he could beat any hedge fund investor over 10 years with an S&P index fund. Protégé Partners LLC accepted, and the two parties placed a million-dollar bet. Buffett won the bet.
 

Sportin' Wood

Well-Known Member
Joined
Sep 24, 2007
Messages
2,745
Reaction score
8,264
If it does not happen this next year, how long are you prepared to wait? What’s the opportunity cost of waiting? If is does happen this year, and you buy, what if it gets worse in 2024 and beyond?

You have first mover advantage now, but you probably won’t get bottom dollar
(whatever that will end up being).

If you bought in 2008 when opportunity was in the air, does that 10-15% price delta from 08 to 11 really even matter today?
There are a lot of factors that make each situation unique. Age plays a big part. While my job is pretty secure, my location is not. At a moment's notice, I may have to move to almost anywhere in the world. I chose to sell everything based on my previous history and what I know about my future. I'm in Havasu now, enjoying the weather and view, understanding that it could change. The last thing I wanted was to be stuck with a house and have to move. So I sold pretty close to the top.

We have multiple topics in this thread; I'm still in the camp of people who think we should be careful. The economy does not seem to be built on a solid foundation. Those that say 2008 can't happen again are right; each situation is unique. For many, 2008 caused enough pain that it impacted people who might not usually feel the sting, but because the lead-up is different, there are clues that point to cracks in the foundation.

To answer your first question, I might have to wait or seriously downsize my expectations of what and where I want to buy and what I can buy. I'm actively shopping, but I've not seen "The forever Home." There are some deals to be had. We actually purchased a property in 2022.
 

cofooter

Well-Known Member
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
6,115
Reaction score
10,595
There are a lot of factors that make each situation unique. Age plays a big part. While my job is pretty secure, my location is not. At a moment's notice, I may have to move to almost anywhere in the world. I chose to sell everything based on my previous history and what I know about my future. I'm in Havasu now, enjoying the weather and view, understanding that it could change. The last thing I wanted was to be stuck with a house and have to move. So I sold pretty close to the top.

We have multiple topics in this thread; I'm still in the camp of people who think we should be careful. The economy does not seem to be built on a solid foundation. Those that say 2008 can't happen again are right; each situation is unique. For many, 2008 caused enough pain that it impacted people who might not usually feel the sting, but because the lead-up is different, there are clues that point to cracks in the foundation.

To answer your first question, I might have to wait or seriously downsize my expectations of what and where I want to buy and what I can buy. I'm actively shopping, but I've not seen "The forever Home." There are some deals to be had. We actually purchased a property in 2022.
I'm going with "Its going to get worse before it gets better" and am in no hurry to risk anything right now. I'm thinking 6-9 mths we'll have a much better idea of the opportunities.
 

~JM~

Well-Known Member
Joined
Sep 7, 2022
Messages
248
Reaction score
344
 

rrrr

Well-Known Member
Joined
Dec 19, 2007
Messages
16,390
Reaction score
37,062
I believe the probability of China invading Taiwan has exponentially increased in the last 24 months, as it has become apparent that Joe Biden and the Democratic clown show he assembled to govern has no idea how to formulate and execute a cogent and effective foreign policy response to the gathering clouds of war.

The Chinese Communist Party (CCP) has a fully developed intricate plan to take over Taiwan, and will also continue to extend their influence across the world by providing money and expertise to developing countries. The Chinese are executing this plan through a foreign policy known as the Belt and Road Initiative.


China has been closely following Russia's invasion of Ukraine, and specifically the United State's reaction to Putin's aggressive and inhumane attacks that are targeting the civilian understructure. Biden's historical record of foreign policy failures has reached a new low with his handling of the conflict, and it is clear Russia has correctly deduced the US will not act to halt the aggressions being foisted upon the vulnerable civilian population.

It is obvious that Putin intends the outcome of the conflict to be victory on his terms. He will not participate in a negotiated settlement. Biden's continued escalation of the war by providing billions of dollars in cash and sophisticated military equipment will eventually force Putin to utilize tactical nuclear weapons on the battlefield.

When this threshold is passed, China will begin their invasion of Taiwan. The United State's inability to force containment of Chinese aggression will result in the establishment of a CCP government in Taiwan. The forgotten lessons of Communist governance will be brought into focus once again, with purges and executions slashing through the ranks of Taiwanese political and intellectual figures.

The Democratic focus on LGBTQIA+ ( :rolleyes: ) issues while World War III is beginning to boil could easily escalate to a catastrophe which will cause massive destruction and death. We can only hope that elections held in November 2024 will install a government that is strong enough to reverse the idiocy of the disastrous Biden presidency.
 

pronstar

President, Dallas Chapter
Joined
Aug 5, 2009
Messages
34,706
Reaction score
41,570
I believe the probability of China invading Taiwan has exponentially increased in the last 24 months, as it has become apparent that Joe Biden and the Democratic clown show he assembled to govern has no idea how to formulate and execute a cogent and effective foreign policy response to the gathering clouds of war.

The Chinese Communist Party (CCP) has a fully developed intricate plan to take over Taiwan, and will also continue to extend their influence across the world by providing money and expertise to developing countries. The Chinese are executing this plan through a foreign policy known as the Belt and Road Initiative.


China has been closely following Russia's invasion of Ukraine, and specifically the United State's reaction to Putin's aggressive and inhumane attacks that are targeting the civilian understructure. Biden's historical record of foreign policy failures has reached a new low with his handling of the conflict, and it is clear Russia has correctly deduced the US will not act to halt the aggressions being foisted upon the vulnerable civilian population.

It is obvious that Putin intends the outcome of the conflict to be victory on his terms. He will not participate in a negotiated settlement. Biden's continued escalation of the war by providing billions of dollars in cash and sophisticated military equipment will eventually force Putin to utilize tactical nuclear weapons on the battlefield.

When this threshold is passed, China will begin their invasion of Taiwan. The United State's inability to force containment of Chinese aggression will result in the establishment of a CCP government in Taiwan. The forgotten lessons of Communist governance will be brought into focus once again, with purges and executions slashing through the ranks of Taiwanese political and intellectual figures.

The Democratic focus on LGBTQIA+ ( :rolleyes: ) issues while World War III is beginning to boil could easily escalate to a catastrophe which will cause massive destruction and death. We can only hope that elections held in November 2024 will install a government that is strong enough to reverse the idiocy of the disastrous Biden presidency.


At the first hint of an invasion, I believe plans will be set in motion to evacuate top chipmaker talent, and I believe we will destroy the highest tech chip factories, leaving China with little to show for their efforts.
 

RiverDave

In it to win it
Joined
Sep 13, 2007
Messages
126,862
Reaction score
166,830
At the first hint of an invasion, I believe plans will be set in motion to evacuate top chipmaker talent, and I believe we will destroy the highest tech chip factories, leaving China with little to show for their efforts.

If China just stopped production of everything they export to the western nations it would be enormously crippling..

I believe they are doing these Covid lockdowns on a plan to see how had it hurts us..

If we get involved in them and Taiwan it’s gonna be a shit show and likely the beginning of WW3
 

pronstar

President, Dallas Chapter
Joined
Aug 5, 2009
Messages
34,706
Reaction score
41,570
If China just stopped production of everything they export to the western nations it would be enormously crippling..

I believe they are doing these Covid lockdowns on a plan to see how had it hurts us..

If we get involved in them and Taiwan it’s gonna be a shit show and likely the beginning of WW3

It’s also a two-way street.
China needs us to keep their manufacturing base working.

Very good synopsis of the situation here

 

Sportin' Wood

Well-Known Member
Joined
Sep 24, 2007
Messages
2,745
Reaction score
8,264
Surprisingly honest talk from an RV dealership. A bit long, but he shares some good stats about sales and manufacturing.


 

rrrr

Well-Known Member
Joined
Dec 19, 2007
Messages
16,390
Reaction score
37,062
Surprisingly honest talk from an RV dealership. A bit long, but he shares some good stats about sales and manufacturing.


For years I've wondered about the flooring plan costs for RV dealers. There are some stores located in small towns miles from a major market that have well over $3-$5 million in inventory.

Sherman, TX is on the Texas and Oklahoma border about 80 miles north of Dallas. There are three different RV dealers on the highway leading into town from the south, and their lots are stuffed full of product.

Can anyone provide insight into how these guys survive?
 

Englewood

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jun 12, 2012
Messages
4,013
Reaction score
6,776
I may be naive, but a change in the interest rate does not price me out of the market as much as dramatic swings in home prices. While I would like to take advantage of rates as we saw in 2021, I believe those created more long-term harm to the economy than good.
I disagree...

$600,000 last year @ 4% = $2,864/mo
$550,000 this year @ 6.5% = $3,792/mo

The 600k house mentioned above would have to drop to $450,000 to have a similar payment at 600k. That will be about a 30%+ decline from the top. While I do believe we will give back covid gains (20% ish), if prices drop 30% people will be buying again.
 

530RL

Well-Known Member
Joined
Sep 18, 2012
Messages
22,600
Reaction score
22,053
I disagree...

$600,000 last year @ 4% = $2,864/mo
$550,000 this year @ 6.5% = $3,792/mo

The 600k house mentioned above would have to drop to $450,000 to have a similar payment at 600k. That will be about a 30%+ decline from the top. While I do believe we will give back covid gains (20% ish), if prices drop 30% people will be buying again.
Absent a drop in wages, a 30 percent drop in housing prices will make it very difficult to bring new inventory upon the market.
 

Sportin' Wood

Well-Known Member
Joined
Sep 24, 2007
Messages
2,745
Reaction score
8,264
I disagree...

$600,000 last year @ 4% = $2,864/mo
$550,000 this year @ 6.5% = $3,792/mo

The 600k house mentioned above would have to drop to $450,000 to have a similar payment at 600k. That will be about a 30%+ decline from the top. While I do believe we will give back covid gains (20% ish), if prices drop 30% people will be buying again.
I am not as concerned with the monthly as I am in the 20% down requirements burning my cash. Somewhere in all this math is a tipping point where the 20% down payment increase for inflated pricing intersects with the increase in interest rates.

I would instead take the lower purchase price, property taxes, and transaction fees than see hyperinflation in the real estate market, as we have seen recently—refi on the rebound.

The barrier to entry hits the FHA/VA 3% down folks at the down payment and the monthly pretty hard, there is no doubt. Imagine all that and PMI?


I'm thinking of a conventional 20% down situation where the increase in interest might play a different role in the trade-off. Someone way more intelligent than me could likely whip up some quick stats that point to how an 18% home loan was not such a big deal when the house price was $30K
 

HTMike

OG
Joined
Jul 27, 2008
Messages
828
Reaction score
1,540
Absent a drop in wages, a 30 percent drop in housing prices will make it very difficult to bring new inventory upon the market.

Not for people who purchased houses before 2021.
 

77charger

Well-Known Member
Joined
Dec 19, 2007
Messages
6,576
Reaction score
8,675
Who the heck would want to stay at the Quality Inn when there are AirBNB for the same price???
Lol I look at final price not advertised Airbnb which will have a cleaning fee anyways hotel in my case is still cheaper and less hassle. Besides I only need a hotel to just sleep.

Usually gone in boat most of the day return for shower then head out to eat then back for sleep. I’ll spend the savings at topock for lunch
 

LargeOrangeFont

We aren't happy until you aren't happy
Joined
Sep 4, 2015
Messages
49,689
Reaction score
76,183
I am not as concerned with the monthly as I am in the 20% down requirements burning my cash. Somewhere in all this math is a tipping point where the 20% down payment increase for inflated pricing intersects with the increase in interest rates.

I would instead take the lower purchase price, property taxes, and transaction fees than see hyperinflation in the real estate market, as we have seen recently—refi on the rebound.

The barrier to entry hits the FHA/VA 3% down folks at the down payment and the monthly pretty hard, there is no doubt. Imagine all that and PMI?


I'm thinking of a conventional 20% down situation where the increase in interest might play a different role in the trade-off. Someone way more intelligent than me could likely whip up some quick stats that point to how an 18% home loan was not such a big deal when the house price was $30K

That $900 more a month on a lower purchase price with higher interest would only hurt your cash for 3 years in that scenario vs. the higher price/lower interest. Then it is 27 years of having an extra $900/month.

That seems like a decent trade off to paying $900 more a month in interest for 30 years hoping for a drop in rates.

Although you don’t really have a choice unless you have a time machine I suppose.

I’d put more down on a higher price/lower interest deal like that every time.
 

Sportin' Wood

Well-Known Member
Joined
Sep 24, 2007
Messages
2,745
Reaction score
8,264
That $900 more a month on a lower purchase price with higher interest would only hurt your cash for 3 years in that scenario vs. the higher price/lower interest. Then it is 27 years of having an extra $900/month.

That seems like a decent trade off to paying $900 more a month in interest for 30 years hoping for a drop in rates.

Although you don’t really have a choice unless you have a time machine I suppose.

I’d put more down on a higher price/lower interest deal like that every time.
That's assuming you keep the house and the mortgage. Smart Money may agree that the lower interest rate is more attractive even at the higher costs of the home. I'm just willing to trade higher interest rates in exchange for the reduction of speculative buyers driving up the costs of homes. Too much OPM (other people's money) in the system seemed to turn people into spending like drunken sailors. The Cheapest apple video comes to mind.


I hope we agree that each situation is unique, but let's assume the life cycle of a mortgage into the equation.

This morning I was thinking about two scenarios and which I would rather be in.

Let's imagine the same house in Austin, Texas. I work for SalesForce Dual income family with two and a half kids. My wife works as a Real Estate Sales Person.
Scenario 1.)
I bought at the top of the market and moved here for a tech job. Low-interest rate, but now I am $75K underwater. No biggie, It costs about the same as rent in this town.
Scenario 2.)
Paying a higher interest rate, and the mortgage payment is slightly higher than rent, but I have $75K in equity.

Today I got my pink slip because Salesforce is cutting 10% of the workforce. I will lose my medical insurance; my wife will have to go on maternity leave. I have a job offer in California. The RE market is a train wreck, the wife has not sold shit in two months, rental market is flat. I've got two new cars that are upside down.


I may not have learned how to make a lot of money, but I have learned that having an escape plan has served me well over the years without bankruptcy or repossession.

I'm not convinced the low-interest rate will be much of an influencing factor for the above examples.

One of the Silverbacks in the park told me yesterday he sold two short sales a week in one year during the great recession. He felt like those days are going to return.

It's taken 50 years for me to learn to listen to my elders.
 

LargeOrangeFont

We aren't happy until you aren't happy
Joined
Sep 4, 2015
Messages
49,689
Reaction score
76,183
That's assuming you keep the house and the mortgage. Smart Money may agree that the lower interest rate is more attractive even at the higher costs of the home. I'm just willing to trade higher interest rates in exchange for the reduction of speculative buyers driving up the costs of homes. Too much OPM (other people's money) in the system seemed to turn people into spending like drunken sailors. The Cheapest apple video comes to mind.


I hope we agree that each situation is unique, but let's assume the life cycle of a mortgage into the equation.

This morning I was thinking about two scenarios and which I would rather be in.

Let's imagine the same house in Austin, Texas. I work for SalesForce Dual income family with two and a half kids. My wife works as a Real Estate Sales Person.
Scenario 1.)
I bought at the top of the market and moved here for a tech job. Low-interest rate, but now I am $75K underwater. No biggie, It costs about the same as rent in this town.
Scenario 2.)
Paying a higher interest rate, and the mortgage payment is slightly higher than rent, but I have $75K in equity.

Today I got my pink slip because Salesforce is cutting 10% of the workforce. I will lose my medical insurance; my wife will have to go on maternity leave. I have a job offer in California. The RE market is a train wreck, the wife has not sold shit in two months, rental market is flat. I've got two new cars that are upside down.


I may not have learned how to make a lot of money, but I have learned that having an escape plan has served me well over the years without bankruptcy or repossession.

I'm not convinced the low-interest rate will be much of an influencing factor for the above examples.

One of the Silverbacks in the park told me yesterday he sold two short sales a week in one year during the great recession. He felt like those days are going to return.

It's taken 50 years for me to learn to listen to my elders.
Every situation is different..

You could also write that scenario as wife gets job, and you hold out for another tech job in your local Austin market. Unless there is a huge raise associated with taking your tech job from Austin to CA (there is not typically) moving to CA makes your problems worse. At best in that scenario even if under water keep the Austin house, rent it out and rent in CA.

I’m in tech, and quite honestly there are more remote job listings than I have ever seen. Austin is a tech hotbed so maybe that isn’t the best example, but I get your point.

In fact I am probably representative of your example with maybe more risk as I am in a spot with fewer tech opportunities than where I moved from.

Everyone’s escape plan is different. Yours sounds like fleeing to higher ground, mine is that I have monthly costs structured so I could take a job at the local Home Depot and make ends meet if needed.
 
Last edited:

Gonefishin5555

Well-Known Member
Joined
Aug 8, 2020
Messages
1,180
Reaction score
1,796
That's assuming you keep the house and the mortgage. Smart Money may agree that the lower interest rate is more attractive even at the higher costs of the home. I'm just willing to trade higher interest rates in exchange for the reduction of speculative buyers driving up the costs of homes. Too much OPM (other people's money) in the system seemed to turn people into spending like drunken sailors. The Cheapest apple video comes to mind.


I hope we agree that each situation is unique, but let's assume the life cycle of a mortgage into the equation.

This morning I was thinking about two scenarios and which I would rather be in.

Let's imagine the same house in Austin, Texas. I work for SalesForce Dual income family with two and a half kids. My wife works as a Real Estate Sales Person.
Scenario 1.)
I bought at the top of the market and moved here for a tech job. Low-interest rate, but now I am $75K underwater. No biggie, It costs about the same as rent in this town.
Scenario 2.)
Paying a higher interest rate, and the mortgage payment is slightly higher than rent, but I have $75K in equity.

Today I got my pink slip because Salesforce is cutting 10% of the workforce. I will lose my medical insurance; my wife will have to go on maternity leave. I have a job offer in California. The RE market is a train wreck, the wife has not sold shit in two months, rental market is flat. I've got two new cars that are upside down.


I may not have learned how to make a lot of money, but I have learned that having an escape plan has served me well over the years without bankruptcy or repossession.

I'm not convinced the low-interest rate will be much of an influencing factor for the above examples.

One of the Silverbacks in the park told me yesterday he sold two short sales a week in one year during the great recession. He felt like those days are going to return.

It's taken 50 years for me to learn to listen to my elders.
I’d want the scenario with the equity it gives you the ability to sell easily and move if you need to. Also can refi later. Also slight negative rental cash flow not a big deal as you are also paying down principal so not a true negative.
 

LargeOrangeFont

We aren't happy until you aren't happy
Joined
Sep 4, 2015
Messages
49,689
Reaction score
76,183
I’d want the scenario with the equity it gives you the ability to sell easily and move if you need to. Also can refi later. Also slight negative rental cash flow not a big deal as you are also paying down principal so not a true negative.

I’d argue that slightly negative cash flow on a rental is a true negative with maintenance rolled into it.
 
Top